Benchmark Fuel
DEAL #GAS-1349
OPPORTUNITY BREAKDOWN
PREPARED JUNE 2026
CONFIDENTIAL
Opportunity & Value Proposition

Two 76 Stores, One Market,
Volume To Capture

346 & 704 Bells Highway, Walterboro, SC  ·  Operations Only  ·  $250,000 Package
Data Status

Figures are drawn from the seller deal sheet. Fuel gross profit is calculated directly from stated volume and the $0.27 margin. Inside gross profit is modeled at 30% and net income is illustrative, both pending the overhead P&L or store POS. Items tagged MODELED are not yet verified to actuals.

01 Snapshot
Package
$250,000
Operations only
Per Store
$125,000
Sold together or apart
Brand
76
Two-store cluster
Structure
Leased
Real estate not included

Two 76-branded operations on the same road in Walterboro, less than a mile apart. Low capital entry at $125,000 a door, real estate leased rather than owned, and enough density to run both as a single market with shared oversight and buying. The story here is not the stabilized cash flow, it is the room to grow fuel volume against a healthy per-gallon margin and a rent structure that does not punish growth.

02 The Economics

Per store and combined, monthly. Fuel gross profit is hard math from the stated volume and margin. Inside gross profit carries a 30% assumption that has to be confirmed against the actual category mix.

Line (monthly)346 Bells704 BellsCombined
Inside sales$50,000$50,000$100,000
Fuel volume (gal)18,00021,00039,000
Fuel GP @ $0.27$4,860$5,670$10,530
Inside GP @ 30%MODELED$15,000$15,000$30,000
Gross profit$19,860$20,670$40,530
Less rent (Option 1)$3,040$3,130$6,170
GP after rent, before overhead$16,820$17,540$34,360

Annualized, that is roughly $412,000 a year of gross profit after rent across the pair, before payroll, utilities, insurance, and maintenance.

03 Rent Structure, Pick The Variable Option

The landlord offers two lease structures per store. At these volumes the choice is not close.

Option 1  RECOMMENDED
~$3,100 / mo
$2,500 NNN plus $0.03 per gallon. Lands near $3,040 at 346 and $3,130 at 704.
Option 2
$9,500 / mo
Flat rate. Only wins above about 233,000 gallons a month per store. These do 18,000 to 21,000.

Choosing the variable structure saves roughly $6,400 a month per store at current volume and keeps occupancy cost moving only three cents for every gallon of growth. The flat rate is a trap at this volume and should not be on the table for a buyer.

04 The Net Picture Is Still Pending

A true net cannot be stated yet, because the deal sheet carries no payroll, utilities, insurance, or maintenance. For a store at $50K inside plus light fuel, non-rent overhead typically runs $10K to $16K a month. The figures below are illustrative at a $13K mid-estimate, not verified.

Illustrative (annual)346 Bells704 BellsCombined
Net @ ~$13K/mo overheadMODELED~$45,840~$54,480~$100,320
Implied multiple2.7x2.3x2.5x

A 2.5x package multiple is a normal, healthy small-operator number, not a distressed buy and not the 1.2x outlier some larger packages show. But it swings entirely on the real overhead, so the operating P&L is the first document to pull.

05 Value Proposition

The headline is the volume upside. 18,000 to 21,000 gallons a month is light for a fuel site. That is either an underused asset or a soft location, and which one it is decides the deal. If these sites can be grown, the math is direct:

Every +10,000 gal / month = +$2,700 / month gross profit

Rent only moves three cents on each of those gallons, so growth drops almost entirely to the bottom line. This is an operator's growth play, not a stabilized cash cow.

Low Capital Entry

$125,000 a door, $250,000 for the pair. Accessible to a first acquisition or an expanding operator.

Two-Store Density

Both sites on Bells Highway, under a mile apart. One market, shared management, combined buying.

Healthy Fuel Margin

$0.27 per gallon is a strong margin to grow volume against, well above commodity-grade pricing.

Growth-Friendly Lease

The variable rent keeps fixed cost low now and scales gently, rewarding the operator who grows gallons.

06 What To Pull Before Pricing Or Positioning
  • The overhead P&L or store POS for both sites, so we can state a real net the way we do on verified deals instead of modeling it.
  • Actual inside margin and category mix. 30% is an assumption. A tobacco-heavy mix runs lower and changes the gross.
  • The reason fuel volume is low. Traffic counts, nearby competition, and store hours separate hidden upside from a weak corner.
  • Lease length, renewal, and escalator terms, plus any cap on the $0.03 per gallon. On an operations-only deal the lease is the only downside protection.
  • The 76 fuel-supply agreement, including volume commitments and pricing, since it governs the margin the whole thesis rests on.
  • Confirmation of the round figures. Identical $50K inside and $125K pricing at both stores read like estimates. Verify to actuals before anything goes public.
Benchmark Fuel
615-386-0013  ·  9005 Overlook Blvd, Brentwood, TN 37027  ·  Info@BenchmarkInvestorsGroup.com
TN License No. 261937  |  AL License No. 000134215-0. Benchmark Fuel is a registered d/b/a of Benchmark Investors Group, Inc.
A 3% buyer fee is payable to Benchmark Fuel at closing. In cooperation with licensed broker of record Brian Brockman, Bang Realty-South Carolina Inc., SC License No. 108250.
Confidential opportunity breakdown. Fuel gross profit calculated from seller-stated volume and margin. Inside margin and net income modeled and pending verification against store records. Buyer to independently verify all income and expenses in due diligence. Not an offer or a guarantee of performance.